Kinder Eggs can’t be brought into the United States, but that’s no reason your family can’t enjoy chocolate surprise eggs. Seriously, you make make them yourself! All you need is a few plastic egg toys and some chocolate candy melts. Note: the plastic egg toys should separate vertically rather than horizontally. We found ours at a dollar store.

Things You’ll Need

12 oz. bag of chocolate candy melts
12 oz. bag of white candy melts
Large plastic toy eggs
Small plastic toy eggs
Assortment of small candies or toys
Step 1: Prepare the Plastic Eggs
Wash and thoroughly dry the plastic eggs.

Place a few candies or toys inside the small plastic eggs.

Step 2: Melt the Chocolate
Pour the chocolate candy melts into a microwaveable bowl. Heat for 15 to 20 seconds, then stir. The candy melts will not look at all melted, but it’s important to stir them before heating again. Repeat two times, stirring each time.

Step 3: Coat the Inside of the Plastic Egg
Spoon melted chocolate into one half of a large plastic egg, and smooth out the layer. Pour out any excess chocolate. Repeat with remaining halves. Refrigerate until the chocolate is completely set. Repeat to add a second coat to each egg half

Following the instructions in Step 2, melt the white chocolate. Spoon white chocolate over the two coats of chocolate inside each plastic egg half. Refrigerate until the white chocolate is completely set.

Step 4: Fill and Seal the Egg Halves
Preheat an oven to 250 degrees F. Set a cookie sheet in the oven to heat up.

Use a knife to smooth the edges of the chocolate, making sure no chocolate drips extend over the edges of the plastic eggs.

Pop the chocolate out of the plastic.

Put the heated cookie sheet onto a heat-proof surface and press two chocolate egg halves onto it.

Quickly set a small plastic egg into one half. Top with the other half.

Immediately press the two together.

Press the bottom of the chocolate egg onto the cookie sheet to flatten it so the egg can sit up.

Step 5: Package the Chocolate Eggs
Wrap each egg in foil. Or, use cellophane tied at the top with a ribbon.

Step 6: Celebrate
Supervise children as they open their surprise eggs. They may need a bit of help opening the chocolate eggs because the chocolate layers may be a little thicker than on commercial eggs. If necessary, use a sharp knife to perforate the edges in a few places so your child can break the egg apart.